I got the dreaded Site Message that said I had "unnatural inbound links." Got the same message 9/7/12. Did a disavow list, submitted a reconsideration, and got "manual spam action revoked" on 11/30/12. Been so spooked by it that I never did anymore linking. My site never recovered any rankings. Without doing any linking in a year and a half I received this new message.
I did what the message told me to do by downloading "links to your site." There were 7,000 links "first discovered" going back to 12/24/04. I checked the latest 500 links from 2/25 to 4/10 of this year. Of those 500 urls, 310 do not contain my link either on the page directly or when viewing "page source." I have a feeling that if I go through the entire list of 7,000, probably 4,500 will not contain my link. Of the remaining 2,500 I have a feeling that many will have been included in my original disavow list in the fall of 2012.
Can anyone answer:
1. Why is WMT reporting these links erroneously?
2. And most importantly, what is my best course of action to get google to modify the list to reflect "unnatural inbound links" that actually exist.