Great community. Great ideas.
Welcome to SEOChat, a community dedicated to helping beginners and professionals alike in improving their Search Engine Optimization knowledge. Sign up today to gain access to the combined insight of tens of thousands of members.
Jan 14th, 2013, 02:16 PM
Request for Reconsideration Rejections
We own several websites and all were really hit hard by Google's Penguin update in April, and the EMD in September totally wiped them all out of the SERPs. The problem was due to affiliate links as we had tons and tons of links among the websites. After determining the exact cause for our penalty, we began working to fix this problem by removing all these links. In December, after thinking we had removed all the links, we submitted a Request for Reconsideration to Google. Within Days, Google rejected our Request.
So, back to the drawing board! We spent weeks verifying that all the links had been removed and about two weeks ago, submitted another Request for Reconsideration to Google. Within 10 days Google responded that we were still in violation of their policies for unnatural linkings. So again, after totally reviewing the sites and finding NO inter linkings, we concluded that Google has NOT re-crawled our sites after we have removed all the inter linking.
We just assumed Google would Re-crawl our sites before reviewing our Request, but apparently we are wrong.
Has anyone else had this problem? If so, how did you handle it? And, does anyone have any advice or suggestions for us? Thanks for your comments, thoughts and suggestions.
Jan 14th, 2013, 03:17 PM
Have you considered that Google's problem may not be with YOUR sites but rather with someone else linking TO your sites. Google doesn't need to crawl your site to see those bad links are still up.
BTW. I wouldn't expect too much sympathy here. If those updates wiped you off the map chances are you didn't have any quality content.
Jan 14th, 2013, 03:33 PM
Sounds like you're better off just closing the sites and relaunching.
Jan 14th, 2013, 03:40 PM
Yea, I wouldn't expect too much sympathy except that I'm not alone here. And, you might be right about quality content, EXCEPT for the fact that our sites maintained top 5 serps for over 5 years. But, thanks for your input. The truth is hard to swallow, and you might be right.
Jan 14th, 2013, 04:39 PM
Just because you ranked for 5 years doesn't mean you have quality content, beings how you were hit with Penguin means you were ranking on spammy links then the EMD which I believe was really a panda update that cleaned out poor content sites with EMDs and other sites as well.
What industry are you in?
Jan 14th, 2013, 05:16 PM
You know, I joined this forum hoping to get some insight, and maybe even some good advice, but unfortunately, all I've gotten is 'advice' and 'help' like this. Yea, I know we are doing thing / many things wrong due to our penalty, but I was hoping some constructive comments and not a continuation of the beatings we have been getting.
PLEASE, save you criticism and you negative comments / feedback for those in denial.
Originally Posted by Test-ok
Jan 14th, 2013, 07:02 PM
Not really trying to beat a dead horse and I'm sorry you took it that way, that wasn't my intent at all. I mainly wanted to let you know what the two different algos addressed.
Hence the reason for my question...what industry are you in? it wouldn't hurt to see the site your talking about either. We need some additional information to offer any assistance. There must be a reason why Google still thinks your in violation.
The only answer anyone I give with the information supplied is, find the culprit and try again and work on your content.
Jan 14th, 2013, 07:34 PM
Yea, I know, but after playing by the rules for 10+ years, and then having the rug drug out from underneath you isn't very pleasant. We have always enjoyed excellent SERPs by following good and solid seo practices, but I think our big problem is linking among our many affiliate websites. We operated that way for years, until the Google updates this year penalized us and many more site.
And, let me state that we have always been managed by what we think / thought was competent SEO guys, and we have always followed their recommends, especially for bring our sites back in compliance. We are convinced that Google has NOT re-crawled our site, Baby Shower Invitations | Bridal Shower Invitation | Shower Invites to verify all the affiliate links have been removed before reviewing our two Request for Reconsideration.
Anyway, I would have listed the website, but I assumes this forum would not allow links or urls especially for new members. If they will allow, the website is, Baby Shower Invitations | Bridal Shower Invitation | Shower Invites. Any constructive advice or anyone else can give would be greatly appreciated. Thanks
Originally Posted by Test-ok
Jan 14th, 2013, 09:20 PM
When you lump all your problems into one basket you make it confusing to help.
Google PENGUIN... no need to request reconsideration just start promoting the domain again with new links but not of similar style as the ones you got nailed with... e.g. if you used link pages, directory links, blog comment links and forum sig links - avoid these.
EMD... avoid targeting the domain words e.g. if your domain was >custom< & >gifts< target >personalized< & >presents< and and other synonyms and let LSI ranks you for the domain name words.
Jan 15th, 2013, 09:00 AM
Hey... I gave you a place to look.
Joshz may be right. Google is (for good reason) extra tough on previous 'bad citizens'.
Check your alt text though. I looked at moving cards and Google might think you are keyword stuffing.
Also, why is the selection page downloading full size images AND thumbnails?
I would consider doing a full site audit and then re-launching unless you get a LOT of direct traffic.
Jan 15th, 2013, 09:07 AM
I just took a VERY quick look for you. Backlink tools are still showing your old spam interdomain links so google may not have crawled those sites (and therefore sees the old links). Also some of your other links are total spam, with very few good quality links. (most of the rest come from yourself on pinterest and google +)
You may need to recruit some high quality links an possible disavow or have some spam stuff removed.
Jan 15th, 2013, 09:17 AM
I am simply amazed (positively) at some of the observations and comments made here.
How do we get Google to re-crawl the site to see that all the old affiliate / interdomain links have been removed? Anyone have any suggestions?
Secondly, and more importantly, if we do as you suggest,
"You may need to recruit some high quality links"
aren't we getting right back into the forbidden practice of 'buying' links? I know you used the word, 'recruit' but to little guys like me, that can only be accomplished by buying.
Originally Posted by realityhack
Jan 17th, 2013, 11:31 AM
You need to get more creative. There should be a lot of info here on link building. Paid links are almost never high quality anyway.
Some people give high quality content to other webmasters in exchange for a link. Or they may find relevant sites and simply ask the webmaster to link to their site if they think it would be useful to their users.
Also consider the relaunching idea. It might be your fastest most reliable shot given you don't have a ton to loose (established brand, tons of links, etc.)
Jan 17th, 2013, 03:42 PM
My German??? is a little rusty!! But, thanks!!
Originally Posted by vyvoztbomsk
Jan 18th, 2013, 06:16 AM
this is russian and this is spam
By korzon in forum Google Optimization
Last Post: Feb 17th, 2010, 02:33 PM
By KernelPanic in forum Google Optimization
Last Post: Feb 8th, 2010, 04:23 PM
By omegacore in forum Google Optimization
Last Post: Aug 8th, 2008, 03:29 PM
By Kain in forum Google Optimization
Last Post: May 27th, 2008, 01:19 AM
By IPM in forum Google Optimization
Last Post: Mar 3rd, 2008, 03:52 AM